Can’t imagine why.

That was your best argument.

It is now common knowledge that pro-Israeli lobbies, with their headquarters in Israel exist in most contries in the Western World. They are behind pro-Jewish/zionist propaganda and anti-Islamic and anti-Palestinian mud-slinging. It is ironic that the very people -or their descendants – who have (rightly) insisted on keeping the memoryof the horrors of the ant-Jewish holocaust alive to prevent such a crime recurring again, are the very ones who have inherited the nazi mantel. The barbarity of Israels treatment of the Palestinians and the recent ‘holocaust’ in Gaza bears testament to the racist nature of this state. The Ethnic-cleansing now being practised in the West bank is reminiscent of Hitler’s Liebensraum, when he wanted to clear large tracts of the East, (as well as getting rid of all jews), to make more living room for his ‘Chosen People”. At present, Israelis are moving into Palestinian territories and evicting families from their homes, to be replaced by jews, some who have left other homes in other countries!
If Israelis are upset that people are now beginning to question Israel’s right to exist, they ought not be surprised. Israel is the main cause of all the unrest in the Middle East, and the development of the growing Islamic Fundamentalism and the terrorist threat can be largely laid at their door. Furthermore, When Jews were persecuted in the West, the forcibly took land belonging to another people, and abused the fact that they were originally allowed to live peacefully alongside the Arabic people who already lived there. it is also interesting that Israelis believe that they legitimately belong to the Middle East, but yet take part in European competitions!

As to the question of a religious organisation having its own state, It does not make sense. No other religion does. Jews from all over the world can also have Israeli citizenship if they should so choose. So where do their allegiance lie? And finally, if one looks at the structure and development of Israel in relation to Democratic States, it has failed! Israel is a deeply racist, sectarian state. It is war-mongering and terrorist in its foreign policy. It is constantly churning up tensions in the area and has been involved in numerous wars. It has nuclear warheads, though it denied it for years. The Israeli economy is not strong and is mainly dependant on what it has stolen, and continues to steal from Palestine; on American support, German subsidies and monies it receives from Jews in other countries. Now, it is involved in genocide against the Palestinians.

Therefore, Israel is a failure, which came into being post 1945, partly through Western guilt for its treatment of its Jewish citizens, and partly because it was easier to help Jewish survivors to stake a claim in Palestine than help them rebuild their broken lives in Europe, with the attendant political, emotional and financial cost of this, and partly through the political astuteness of some US (and possibly some politicians), who saw in israel a foothold in the East. Israel would not survive without the help of its ally, the US.

Note: No, I am not Arabic, Islamic nor ant-Semitic. I believe in the freedom of all religions and the equality of all humankind.

As to the question of a religious organisation having its own state, It does not make sense. No other religion does. Jews from all over the world can also have Israeli citizenship if they should so choose. So where do their allegiance lie? And finally, if one looks at the structure and development of Israel in relation to Democratic States, it has failed! Israel is a deeply racist, sectarian state. It is war-mongering and terrorist in its foreign policy. It is constantly churning up tensions in the area and has been involved in numerous wars. It has nuclear warheads, though it denied it for years. The Israeli economy is not strong and is mainly dependant on what it has stolen, and continues to steal from Palestine; on American support, German subsidies and monies it receives from Jews in other countries. Now, it is involved in genocide against the Palestinians.

Therefore, Israel is a failure, which came into being post 1945, partly through Western guilt for its treatment of its Jewish citizens, and partly because it was easier to help Jewish survivors to stake a claim in Palestine than help them rebuild their broken lives in Europe, with the attendant political, emotional and financial cost of this, and partly through the political astuteness of some US (and possibly some politicians), who saw in israel a foothold in the East. Israel would not survive without the help of its ally, the US.

Note: No, I am not Arabic, Islamic nor ant-Semitic. I believe in the freedom of all religions and the equality of all humankind.